Logicomix: An Epic Search for Truth by Apostolos Doxiadis and Christos Papadimitriou

If the measure of a good book is that it inspires you to action, then this 2010 Tournament of Books contender is a good book.* I am going back to my copy of Ludwig Wittgenstein’s Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus on the strength of the curiosity inspired by this book. Whether a higher recommendation than that for this book can be made, I do not know. Even so, I am not sold on graphic novels as a concept.

As the book begins, a man pages through a book entitled Foundational Quest Draft. He has a thought bubble: “It’s such a sad tale! And yet…” He yawns. He notices the “camera” and apologizes. The man explains who he is and what the book is about. So begins, Logicomix: An Epic Search for Truth.

The explanation given by the man, Apstolos, is as follows:

You see, this isn’t your typical comic book. In fact, when we started work on it, our friends thought we were crazy! And when they did take us seriously it was, as a rule for the wrong reasons. Like thinking the book is something it’s not! Like maybe a “Logic for Dummies” type of thing or perhaps a kind of textbook or a treatise in the guise of a graphic novel. But it’s not! In this, it’s just what 99.9% of comic books are an honest-to-goodness real yarn. Simply, a story!…Ours is rather unusual in this sense: Its heroes are all logicians.

Bertrand Russell is the primary hero, the one we follow most often. The graphic novel has an interesting structure, weaving bits from the creation of Logicomix together with Russell’s childhood, his adulthood, the lives of other logicians, and short attempts to explain the technical issues with which Russell, Wittgenstein, Kurt Gödel, and others were obsessed. The structure is managed fairly seemlessly and, despite jumping from Russell’s childhood to the author’s modern day trip around Athens, it works.

Graphics, I would assume, are an important part of a graphic novel. I am not at all the right person to critique the drawing, but it did not seem particularly groundbreaking or beautiful. There were shifts in style between story sections which, I believe, helps signal to the reader which time period and characters are in the fore. In other words, all I can really say about the graphics is that they were not intrusive which is probably the best compliment I can pay them. They served the story well.

The story itself is an interesting one. The story covers the life of Russell with digressions into the lives of other logicians, basically the development of the modern field of logic until the original vision (a complete logical system that is self-proving) was proven impossible to obtain. The graphic novel, however, left me wanting more. Logicomix is about 313 pages long, not counting the “Notebook” at the end with short entries on key terms and characters. The excerpt above was about a page. My point is that if you condense all the prose into a conventional novel/biography, the book would be less than 100 pages. Hardly enough to provide great detail about either the logic or the characters.

This is not a failing of the book, however. If you want the story of Russell’s life (or the lives of other logicians), there are rigorous biographies (as well as Russell’s autobiography). For the logic, there are excellent summaries as well as the source material (e.g. Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus). These in depth treatments are widely available, but this graphic novel fills a niche.

Logicomix gives enough of each part (the characters, the logic, the story) to leave you wanting more. The authors and illustrators have managed to convey the emotion, the sense of intellectual adventure, and the intriguing stories that pushed the development of logic forward. The ideal audience is likely adolescent or late adolescent boys and girls. They can breeze through this book where the same child/young adult may never be tempted to crack a rigorous biography or philosophical treatise. My daughter is thirteen and paged through it. She was not hooked. Yet. Likely, because she has not yet read enough of Logicomix, but possibly because she is not quite ready for the subtle excitement of the quest for objective, provable truth.

Of course, if the first panel she picked up started with this conversation between Russell and Wittgenstein, I can see the problem:

Russell, you waste so many pages to establish sets! [next panel]

Of course we do, set theory is essential to our argument.

The bloody ass Hilbert calls it a “paradise”! But it is Hell! A Hell through whose gates…[next panel]

…the monster infinity creeps into mathematics!

“Creeps in”? What rot! Infinity is already there from the start, old chap! [next panel]

It’s in the conceptual universe, prior to our poking our puny little brains into it!

Ach, Russell, I am in such pain! [Wittgenstein writhes in agony.]

At first glance, she may not understand the drama of the situation. This is understandable. But it is a bit exciting if you have followed it from the beginning. I am sure of it.

If you do have an interest in the ideas of Russell, Wittgenstein, Gödel, Alan Turing, Georg Cantor, David Hilbert, John Von Neumann, and logicians generally, I can highly recommend the book as an appetite whetter. If you have little interest in their ideas, I highly recommend the book as a way to gain some painless exposure to those ideas. The ideas are fascinating. Do not expect too much. This is a comic book. But it is a very smart comic book and a very successful one.

*Unfortunately for Logicomix, the graphic novel faced Wolf Hall in the first round and, thus, its Cinderella run ended before it began.

Advertisements

8 Responses to Logicomix: An Epic Search for Truth by Apostolos Doxiadis and Christos Papadimitriou

  1. Amy says:

    I liked Logicomix, and I’m not all that interested in math or its origins. Like you, I wasn’t quite convinced about the graphic novel as an art form after I read it. But over the last couple of weeks, I read Stitches and Asterios Polyp, and those did more to convince me of the value of graphic novels, especially the latter, which has beautiful artwork.

  2. Kerry says:

    I actually have a copy of Stitches, so I am looking forward to that. And, I will try to check out Asterios Polyp which sounds like something you don’t want in your colon but, based on your description, sounds intriguing. A quick perusal of others’ reviews (couldn’t find one on your site, though I love your site) suggests Asterios Polyp is the graphic novel for me to read before making a judgment on the genre. Stitches first though.

    Thanks for the comment and the lead.

  3. Sarah says:

    Kerry, I really enjoyed your valiant (and successful) attempt to give the graphic novel a fair assessment. I also am a novice in this field, and like you I am not always clear what to look for in the graphics, struggling with garish colours particularly, even when I understand it as a retro device.

    But this sounds like an interesting variant on the genre, particularly since I am currently reading Cryptonomicon.

    If I may recommend my favourite graphic novel (out of a grand total of the three which I have read!) it would have to be Maus.

  4. Kerry says:

    Sarah,

    Thank you for the recommendation and the empathy with my difficulty evaluating comic book graphics.

    This would make a nice companion piece with Cryptonomicon, one of my favorites from that genre (whatever that is…techno-thriller, sci-fi, cyberpunk…).

    Maus is a contender for third graphic novel I will read. Stitches is in the bag for second.

  5. marco says:

    A couple of further suggestions:

    Shaun Tan’s The Arrival
    http://www.amazon.com/The-Arrival/dp/0439895294

    Alan Moore’s From Hell
    http://www.amazon.com/Hell-Alan-Moore/dp/0958578346/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1273683222&sr=1-1

    They are vastly different works:
    The Arrival is a sequence of wordless panels – you’d be tempted to say pictures worth a thousand words,

    while From Hell is a 580-page Behemoth – dense, multilayered, and complex as any novel.

  6. anokatony says:

    My favorite graphic novel would be Persepolis by Satrapi.

  7. Kerry says:

    Marco and Tony,

    Thank you for the additional suggestions. I am new to the genre and intend to ease in, but all these ideas are excellent and give me tempting possibilities for building on my meager graphic novel exposure.

    Thanks!

  8. […] HW: “…a very smart comic book and a very successful one.“ […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: